Sarah Osborn shares her experience in the music business world

Name: Sarah Osborn

Job Title: Director

Firm/Company: West Lanvale Creative

Tell me a bit about yourself.

I have recently founded my own company, West Lanvale Creative, after 16 years working in music publishing. Having worked as a publisher and been only one of a handful of people to have run the trade association I have a pretty unique perspective on music publishing. West Lanvale Creative offers consultancy and project management services to music publishers and those working in related industries. My current client list includes Audio Network, Imagem and boutique media law firm JWSS.

Prior to that I spent three fast and furious years at the Music Publishers Association (MPA), galvanizing the music publishing community, lobbying government and increasing professional development opportunities to the publishing workforce.

The early part of my career was spent in the promotion teams (‘classical A&R’) of two large indie publishers. I travelled the world working alongside composers and persuading conductors, orchestras and opera houses to perform, record and broadcast the music in my catalogue.

That’s amazing, you’ve covered many bases in the industry! What are your areas of specialisation?

Knowledge wise its music publishing as you’d expect. Specifically reprographic rights, piracy and global digital rights.

More generally, working at the MPA taught me a lot about working with diverse groups of people, often with competing interests, so I would say that I am skilled at bringing people together, making sure they’re all heard and finding areas of common ground. 

Do you have a creative background?

Like a lot of people I had aspirations to be a performer until the penny dropped that I wasn’t quite good enough to make it professionally. At which point I decided the second best thing would be to work directly alongside creative people which led me to publishing. The bulk of my career as a publisher was spent supporting and promoting contemporary classical composers. I managed people like Gavin Bryars and Mark-Anthony Turnage alongside working to exploit a rich heritage catalogue that included O Fortuna (from Carl Orff’s Carmina Burana), Frank Zappa and Ligeti (whose music was famously used in 2001:A Space Odyssey).

You have a BMus degree from Goldsmiths University; did you study anything else further or was a degree enough to get you where you are today?

A music degree and the ability to pick things up along the way is what got me to CEO of the MPA but a postgrad or professional qualification would have made things a whole lot easier! To put things into context I was the first non-lawyer to hold the role of CEO of the MPA for about 20 years.

Incredible! Could you talk a bit about what you do in the average week at work?

I generally have two types of day – those spent at home which are meeting and phone free which provide me the time and space to get my head down and work through a knotty problem a client has challenged me to solve.

And at the other end of the spectrum those days spent in London with non-stop meetings. It’s important to me to keep up to date and the best way to join the dots between projects and clients. Many times it’s been a passing comment or asking for someone’s opinion on something which has opened a door or allowed a piece of the jigsaw for a client to fall into place.

You have had many jobs in the music industry from being a Promotions Assistant to Head of Contemporary Music to being a Chief Executive, which has been your favourite and why?

It would have to be being Chief Executive of the MPA. It was certainly the toughest but being able to facilitate real change to benefit an entire industry is an incredibly motivating and hugely rewarding experience. That said I am enjoying being the boss of my own company but it’s very early days and a bit too soon to say if this is my favourite job!

What would you say is your biggest triumph career wise?

Being involved in the establishment of Printed Music Licensing Ltd. This is a subsidiary company of the MPA set up to license the photocopying of sheet music in schools. The photocopier has been the curse of the sheet music publisher from the 1970s onwards and was one of the first instances of mass piracy against the music industry. By legitimizing this practice over £3m of revenue was brought into the music publishing industry in the first year alone as a result of the government purchasing a licence for every state school in England.

How would a new artist go about protecting their music?

Decide what your boundaries are and what you feel comfortable with. If you give away your music for free, at what point will you start charging for it? Would it be better to charge from the outset, no matter how small the licence fee may be to establish the principle that your music has a value? Crucially, you need to weigh up whether you have the means to do anything about it if your music is being used in a way you’re unhappy with.

The next thing is to know where your music is being used. You can’t protect it if you have no idea who is using it. Keep track of who you send it to and always be clear about what you will and won’t allow someone to do.

On a practical level songwriters should register their works with PRS for Music. That will ensure that firstly your works are registered to you and you are eligible to share in royalties from licensed platforms like YouTube, Spotify as well as any royalties generated through radio, TV or from live performance. It also gives you a level of protection by being part of an organization representing over 100,000 members. PRS for Music puts significant resource into lobbying government at both a UK and EU level to ensure that their members interests are represented in policy formulation.

As a performer, assign your records with ISRCs which identify the recording as yours. Register with PPL to ensure you collect any royalties due to you from the public performance of those recordings. Sign up to ContentID on YouTube to control the advertising and have the chance to share in that revenue. BPI has a very active anti-piracy wing that can assist in monitoring illegal activity online.

What is the difference between copyright and a trademark?

Copyright and trademarks are both types of intellectual property. Copyright is the control that’s placed on creative works such as music, books, film and TV. Trademarks protect brands, products and services. 

If you had 3 pieces of advice for aspiring artists who don’t know much about the law/business aspect of the music industry?

  1. Join an organization like the MU or BASCA to meet fellow artists. As well as meeting fellow artists and learning about the industry from more experienced professionals it’s a great way to influence the debate and shape the industry you work in. You also never know who you’re going to meet and what doors might open as a result.
  2. Understand the industry you’re working in. Artists only sign rotten deals because of a lack of knowledge. It’s your career, it’s your responsibility to understand how things work. No excuses.
  3. Budget for getting legal advice. It might seem like a huge cost but it’ll be more costly in the long run if you sign a rubbish deal that needs unpicking. Good lawyers understand that aspiring artists are on a tight budget and will tailor their fee structure accordingly, for example by working on a fixed fee basis and by advising where to focus your budget.

Do you have any advice for aspiring music lawyers?

The best lawyers I’ve worked with don’t get caught up on minutiae at the expense of the bigger picture. They distil an issue down to a handful of key points, sum up the best and worst case scenarios and keep the course of action available simple to understand.

Also, be good fun to be around. If as a client you are going to be spending a lot of time with your lawyer, working late into evening or at weekends on a big deal it’s got to be someone who once it’s all over you want to go for a drink with.

 

Thank you very much to Sarah Osborn for featuring on Always Read The Small Print! If you have any questions please feel free to comment on this article and I will do my best to answer you.

 

Written by: Cherry Johnson

Disclaimer: I am not giving formal legal advice, only the information I gain from research and interviews. If you are unsure of a legal problem you are having please seek advice from a qualified lawyer.

Making Music into Money – Some Ideas

 

Who helps with the distribution of your music?

A Publisher’s primary purpose (and Collection Societies) is to exploit tracks as well as to collect and distribute revenues raised from such exploitation.

How can I get my music out there?

There are many revenue streams that will pay for your music or that can make you money, for example:

  • Radio
  • TV (shows)
  • Video content – YouTube, Vimeo
  • Streaming – Spotify, Tidal, Beats
  • Mobile content
  • Shops, shopping malls, restaurants
  • Clubs, pubs
  • Movie soundtracks, adverts, game soundtracks
  • Sheet music 

Performing live and touring is also a great way to make money doing what you love as well as doing sponsorship deals, endorsements (in music videos and on your social media) and selling merchandise.

How to effectively release a single

 The physical release of a single is very rarely commercially viable, even for an act signed to a major label with good financial support. Cost effectively releasing a record can only be achieved with careful consideration to a number of key issues. You have to make sure you have thought about how much money you are spending on the making of the ‘product’ before anything else. Coming up with a recording budget, knowing the production fees and what royalties you will receive and knowing how much mastering is going to cost you are all parts of the planning of a good single release.

Then there is the packaging and presentation of the product. Depending on whether you are going to be releasing physical copies is something you need to factor into your budget. The list below contains some of the things you need to think about before releasing your single, some are costly and some just require some thought:

  • Sleeve design (someone will have to get paid to make it for you)
  • Track titles
  • Writer credits
  • Catalogue numbers
  • Label information
  • Copyright
  • Web addresses

As mentioned before, the formats in which you want your single to be released play a part in how much money you will be paying out but also how much will be coming back in. You could release the single on CD, as an MP3, on vinyl, on a multi media disc if you want visuals to match (even as a ringtone if you want to be really old school!).

Getting a good lawyer and a team of people who have been in the music publishing business for a while will always be the best way to make sure you get the best ‘deal’ for your work as they will show you the ropes and will guide you to success.

 

Thanks for reading and if you have any questions please feel free to comment on this article and I will do my best to answer you. 

Written by: Cherry Johnson

 

Disclaimer: I am not giving formal legal advice, only the information I gain from research and interviews. If you are unsure of a legal problem you are having please seek advice from a qualified lawyer.

 

Sabine Jones – An Inspiring Interview

Name: Sabine Jones

Job Title: Owner and Founder @ SJ Consultancy

Company: SJ Consultancy

 

Tell me a bit about yourself.

Born and raised in Munich, Germany. Being a “right-brainer”, my passion (and I guess strengths) have always been related to music, art and languages. I left music (piano playing) and art/history (apart from a course in hieroglyphics and Egyptology) behind as ‘hobbies’ and studied to be a translator for English and French. First jobs were with BMG Ariola and GEMA in the early 1990s.

Followed my urge to live abroad and moved to England in 2000 where I continued to work in the music industry and continued to work in the music sector. Left Kobalt Music in 2013 to become self-employed and to try a different approach to my work-life balance.

Amazing achievements! So how did you get the job you are at now?

I studied to be a translator and interpreter in Munich; I am using the spare time I have as a self-employed music industry consultant and translator to do a part-time executive MBA at Henley Business School (special course for the Music & Creative Industries). Due to my rather communicative personality, my networking skills became my main strength and I have been very lucky to be able to rely on the people I have met on my journey, and I do try and work for people pro bono or return favours – you never know when or how it comes back….

Meeting people and making relevant connections is definitely key in an industry like this, your experience definitely shows that… Have you worked at any other music related jobs?

The majority of my career was spent in so-called collecting societies, or Performing Rights Organisations (“PROs”), from GEMA in Germany via PRS in the UK and PAMRA (for artists) in the UK (prior to its merger with PPL) to SWISSPERFORM in Switzerland. A little “break-out” was my job at Nielsen Music, where I was not responsible for royalties but the marketing and sales of data related to radio airplay and digital music downloads.

What are your areas of specialisation?

Copyright – from a royalty collection perspective but also a user perspective (I am a legal translator now and get to translate all kinds of documents, including licensing agreements, e.g. Netflix) and Neighbouring Rights (i.e. the copyright that someone holds in the recording of a musical work e.g. an artist, singer, session musician, and of course the record label). So a paralegal linguist with networking and “getting people together” skills, I guess.

Being able to communicate in multiple languages about something so important is a great success! What made you want to set up your own consultancy business?

After a rather intense career as an Executive, including moving countries, I realised that during my last position – at Kobalt Music, which was probably the most exciting job I ever had – I simply faced the choice to continue or to run out of juice. I was burning my candle at more than two ends! Rather than taking a “sabbatical”, I decided to set up my consultancy, where I would be in control of how much work I would take on. Plus the consultancy provided me with the “time to breathe” and stop and think about myself – which is why I am now doing an MBA as I realised I had not really invested in my own training and development but rather fought other people’s blazes as their firefighter.

Being your own boss, the ultimate dream! You are studying for an MBA at Henley in Music and Creative Industries, how is that going to further benefit your career?

I believe the MBA ‘journey’ will help me to fill any knowledge gaps, without trying to become a jack-of-all-trades. I also expect that it would help me to be better equipped if I decided to return to a full-time executive role. Learning by doing might be a good thing but there comes a time when you need some tools to face the ever-changing environment. Just gut-feeling is not good enough any longer.

Do you have a creative background?

My grandfather was a pianist; I inherited his piano and started to play recorder at the age of 4 and piano at the age of 6. Unfortunately, I haven’t been playing the piano as much as I’d like to in recent years but it’s one of my “back to the roots” activities to do. I also used to sing in a church choir and even made it to Alto soloist in our little Bavarian village.

Could you talk a bit about what you do in the average day at work?

Looking for new clients and doing general admin, this is more than most people would think you have to do when you are self-employed. The actual job itself does not take more than 40-50% of a working day on average (this would be translating a newsletter for a collecting society in Germany or a licensing agreement for another society in Switzerland, or consulting a client on strategic matters e.g. rights issues or business development). Plus of course now the time I need to dedicate to my MBA, which luckily interlinks with some of the consultancy work.

How do you find working with music lawyers?

There were some really pragmatic ones; especially at my last employer I met some great legal ‘players’. Of course it sometimes got hairy as you would usually defend two different viewpoints and each side wanted to get the best deal for their client!

Of course! Your biggest triumph career wise to date?

Not triumph, that’s the wrong word… best job satisfaction ever: to reunite performers with their due neighbouring rights monies while I was running PAMRA, having people like Benny Gallagher, Peter Filleul, Rick Wakeman, Ashley Mason and Mel Gaynor, to name but a few (the list is long!) on the Board of Directors. They all gave their time for free and served the cause because they really believed in it, and so did I. Hardest decision ever: to pluck up the courage and say goodbye to a great company like Kobalt, to go it alone and become self-employed.

How would a new artist go about protecting their music?

In our global age it does not matter where you become a member of a “collecting society”, but do yourself a favour and do it in the country you a) spend most of your time in or perform (also as tax can be a devil) and b) where your language is spoken. I’ve seen cases where a German composer thought his school English was enough for a licensing agreement with an anglo-american record label and it turned out he had signed something he didn’t fully understand. Which resulted in a loss of royalties for him. My advice: do get someone to help you with translations and legal paperwork, or filling in forms and so on, and make sure they do this at a reasonable price for you- if you are an artist, you can’t be a jack of all trades.

And finally, if you had 3 pieces of advice for new artists who don’t know much about the law/business aspect of the music industry?

  • Ask – if you can – some of the “older” artists in the industry and learn from their (often tough) experience but also for their recommendations regarding fair managers and helpful lawyers
  • Attend workshops or lectures by the umbrella organisations for your area (just check the internet for events organized by the Musicians Union, the MPA, PRS for Music, PPL, AIM, etc. etc.)
  • Hang out at the Heights, St. George’s Hotel. There’s a lot of music folks but also people from the Beeb. You never know who you meet there. (and that’s just one example, London’s obviously full of places like that).

 

A huge thank you to Sabine for featuring on Always Read The Small Print! If you have any questions please feel free to comment on this article and I will do my best to answer you.

 

Written by: Cherry Johnson

Disclaimer: I am not giving formal legal advice, only the information I gain from research and interviews. If you are unsure of a legal problem you are having please seek advice from a qualified lawyer.

 

Copyright and the Music Industry – Things You Need To Know

Copyright has been an active law for hundreds of years. The most recent, up to date copyright law is the ‘Copyright Designs and Patents Act’ 1988, this has been amended many times so make sure you check it every now and again before making any big decisions about using other people’s music or protecting your own.

 

So, what is copyright?

In the simplest of terms, it is the right to copy a work. It is a property right and the right to prevent the copying of a work. The creator and the owner of the copyright of a work have the right to earn money from its exploitation.

Copyright criteria

For copyright to subsist in a work it must satisfy the following criteria:

  • Set down in a permanent form (written notation, recorded, videoed etc)
  • Originality (created using skill and effort)

The courts are the only people who determine what the threshold is in terms of what is similar and what has been stolen from another artist. To ensure that your work is protected from day one, the best thing to do is to post a copy of the work to yourself via special delivery. This has a time/date stamp on it so no one can argue that it is fake. Keep the envelope sealed.

Registration

 In the UK* there are no registration requirements. Copyright automatically subsists at the point of creation provided the work satisfies the copyright criteria. Also, you can’t protect the name of a band under copyright, but you can protect it through Trade Descriptions Law.

*Please note, all of the information on this blog is referring to UK Music Law. Other countries can be different so be careful and do more research!

So, how long does copyright last?

 When it comes to literary copyright, the copyright begins from the date the work was set down and lasts until 70 years from the death of the author. If there are several authors involved in the then copyright ends 70 years following the death of the last surviving author.

In terms of sound recording copyright – As of 1st Nov 2013, Copyright in a sound recording lasts for 70 years from the date of recording or 70 years from the date of first release… whichever is longer. When copyright dies it passes into the Public Domain, at this point it is no longer necessary to ask for permission to use it.

If you are working with other artists/musicians/producers, who is the owner of copyright?

The first owner of a musical or literary copyright is normally the person who firsts set the work down in a permanent form, however there are three exceptions to this rule:

  • Exception 1 – If the work is created whilst in employment, the employer will be the first owner of copyright at the point of creation
  • Exception 2 – If the work is created as a result of the composer being commissioned, the commissioner will be the first owner of copyright
  • Exception 3 – If at the time of creation the composer was signed to a publishing contract

If one person writes a song and records it themselves, that person is the creator of the song and owns the copyright to it. However, professionally produced music can have many copyright owners. Copyright to a sound recording may be owner by the songwrite, the producer, the performer, the label, publishers and more!

A more in depth description can be found here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bmm83UD7-00 explained by James Taylor from the Music Business Institute. Also, check out http://www.prsformusic.com/ for more copyright pointers.

 

Thanks for reading and if you have any questions please feel free to comment on this article and I will do my best to answer you.

 

Written by: Cherry Johnson

 

Disclaimer: I am not giving formal legal advice, only the information I gain from research and interviews. If you are unsure of a legal problem you are having please seek advice from a qualified lawyer.

An interview with the owner of Hoare Associates Ltd

Name: Richard Hoare

Job Title: Owner

Firm: Hoare Associates Limited

 

Tell me a little about yourself…

Currently:

“I run Hoare Associates Limited, a forward thinking music business affairs consultancy, focused on independent and electronic music. We provide bespoke, expert advice to innovative and exceptional artists and companies working in music. Most of our work involves helping our clients with creating, understanding, and negotiating their contractual arrangements.

Outside of my work with Hoare Associates I sit on the executive board of the Association for Electronic Music, the international trade organisation for the dance and electronic music community; I am a trustee and director of the charity ‘The Choir with No Name’, which provides choirs for people affected by homelessness and I collect 45rpm singles and am co-founder of the ‘Vintage Mobile Disco’.”

Previously:

“My first job in music, during my university placement year, was in the legal team at BMG Records. After completing my law degree and LPC, I joined Clintons, the UK’s oldest and finest traditional music law firm. I spent 12 years working there, as a trainee, associate, partner and then consultant working alongside the most talented entertainment lawyers in the country. The firm’s roster included a lot of my musical heroes (the Cure, Aphex Twin, Jamiroquai, the Clash, Daft Punk, the Who) and I was fortunate enough to assist in advising many of these, whilst developing my own client base. I was recognised in Chambers and Partners 2013 – 2015 for my work in music law: singled out as the ‘Associate To Watch’.”

What are your areas of specialisation?

“General commercial business affairs advice to individuals and companies working in the music industry.”

Do you have a creative background?

“Not massively…! I was always involved in playing in bands at school, and at university, and at some point that moved into playing records – which I’ve been fortunate enough to keep ticking over whilst I have been doing my day job…”

What and where did you study to get the job you wanted?

“I studied at Bournemouth University – doing a straight LLB law degree – the course was unusual at the time, as it offered a year’s work placement for those students who were able to secure one. I was very fortunate in that I managed to get a year’s work placement at BMG Records in the business affairs department – from the experience and contacts I made there, I was able to secure a training contract at Clintons, where I worked for 12 years after graduating from university.”

What was your first case?

“Whilst I was a trainee, I worked as a part of Clintons’ top litigation team, in a dispute between Simon Cowell’s record company, and the Simon Fuller’s company in relation to the Pop Idol TV Programme and the rights to the winning artists’ recordings. The case settled out of court, but I felt incredibly fortunate to get very involved with the case at such an early stage in my career.”

What does your average day at work look like?

“I no longer do litigious or contentious work. My work is more involved in helping put the deals together for artists and advising on the commercial aspects of those agreements. It’s incredibly varied though, and no two days are the same. I spend about a day a week meeting clients and their managers face to face at their offices and recording studios, as it’s nice to get out from behind my desk from time to time.”

What’s the biggest misconception about entertainment lawyers in your opinion?

“That we’re all the same… as well as the different types of work which we do (e.g. most lawyers will specialize in either contentious (i.e. litigation) or non-contentious (i.e. what I do) work – it’s probably not advisable for a lawyer to try and be an ace at both disciplines – as they involve quite different skills. Within those two main strands there is a huge variety in the style and approach which individual lawyers take. Some lawyers are all about getting the biggest possible deal for their artists – others (and I’d probably include myself in this) view their role as listening carefully to precisely what the artist and their manager consider to be their priorities, and then trying to ensure that we tailor any contractual arrangements accordingly.”

Your biggest triumph career wise?

“Starting my own consultancy last year.”

How would a new artist go about protecting their music?

“The old pre-conceptions of posting a copy of a demotape to yourself, date stamping it, next to copy of today’s newspaper etc etc – are scarcely relevant these days. If an artist is being asked to sign any piece of paper (or even agree to certain specific terms with online services) which confers rights in their recordings or songs, then those artists should definitely speak to someone who has had experience of these types of agreement before signing (ideally a lawyer – but an experienced manager may be able to provide some general advice).”

What is the difference between copyright and a trademark?

“In the course of our work, copyright issues generally relate to the two main products of a musician’s creativity – i.e. a) the songs (lyrics and music) which they write and b) the sound recordings which they make… copyright can also apply to the cover artwork for their records as well as their logos.

Trademarks are most commonly of relevance to artists in relation to their logos and branding – although it is possible I believe (although I’m not a trademark lawyer..) in certain limited circumstances for trademarks to apply to sound – for example, the distinctive sound which plays each time you start up your computer, may be unique enough to be treated like “sound logo” – but this is quite uncommon for most recording artists.”

If you had 3 pieces of advice for new artists who don’t know much about the law aspect of the music industry?

  1. “ Read some great books! Ann Harrison and Don Passman’s books provide great detailed analysis of most legal issues which artists should be aware of – even a basic understanding of the basics will stand you in great stead;
  2. Get a great lawyer! Someone who you trust and can turn to throughout your career – always try and make sure that they come recommended from other artists who you know of and respect;
  3. Don’t be afraid to ask obvious questions – no one knows it all when it comes to music/legal, and anyone who professes to – is probably not the right person to be taking advice from – the people who seem to last longest in the business are the ones who approach every issue afresh, and as an artist, it’s a great habit to get into, to ask questions when you’re not quite sure how something works.”

 

Thank you so much to Richard Hoare for featuring on Always Read The Small Print! If you have any questions please feel free to comment on this article and I will do my best to answer you.

 

Written by: Cherry Johnson

Disclaimer: I am not giving formal legal advice, only the information I gain from research and interviews. If you are unsure of a legal problem you are having please seek advice from a qualified lawyer.

Simon Anderson – The Interview

Last night I had the pleasure of attending Simon Anderson’s seminar ‘Stop me if you think that you’ve heard this one before: music, copyright and plagiarism’. Afterwards, I got in contact with him to do an interview to shed some light on what he does and asked for some advice about the business side of the music industry for you… Here it is!

Simon Anderson – Director of Publishing at Audio Network (a production music library).

Tell me a bit about yourself.

“I have been music-obsessed from an early age and went on to study music at university without a second thought. I didn’t have a particular career path on graduation but landed a job at PRS in London, and from there moved into print music publishing. In 2005 I found Audio Network, where I live the dream of working with brilliant people and amazing composers making the very best music of all genres for film and TV.”

What are your areas of specialisation?

“My team at Audio Network looks after the IP rights that the company owns, so we are responsible for composer contracts, music licensing, royalty collection and analysis, all with a good amount of legal questions and negotiations.”

Do you have a creative background?

“I’m lucky to be able to write the odd track for Audio Network’s library, so get to experience life as a composer as well as a publisher. In my spare time I sing in choirs and play keyboards in a soul band.”

What and where did you study to get the job you wanted?

“I studied music at Edinburgh and went on to read for a postgraduate degree in musicology, followed by a PhD in music research at Durham University. Recently I took the excellent Entertainment Law LLM degree at Westminster University to help widen my understanding of the way the law regulates the music industry.”

He went on to say, “Qualifications aren’t essential to a career in music, but they do help with the deeper understanding of complex areas of music and law. I have some amazing colleagues that came to us straight from school. They are bright, engaged and also nuts about music. We all learn loads on the job too.”

What was your first case?

“Happily in 15 years at Audio Network we haven’t had any litigation. I hope this is largely down to the efficient, ethical and open way that we manage our IP rights.”

Could you talk a bit about what you do in the average day at work?

“One of the joys of working at a young and innovative company is that no two days are the same. Today we’re interviewing a couple of people for a temporary position in our copyright team, and we’re analysing last month’s uses of our music on TV in the USA. Tomorrow our Paris office manager is over and we’re meeting a couple of new composers to explain our business model and royalty flow.”

What’s the biggest misconception about entertainment lawyers in your opinion?

“I’m sure there’s still the old stereotype of the cigar-smoking, whisky-drinking bad guy who is more interested in lining his own pockets, but the IP law firms we work with are smart, savvy and are great at engaging with the industry and sharing knowledge.”

Your biggest triumph career wise?

“A selfish answer – it the first time I heard one of my tracks on TV. It proved to me that Audio Network ‘worked’, and I was so amazed that someone thought my track was the perfect one for that particular scene. It also happened to be in my wife’s favourite programme, ‘Location, Location Location’, so bonus points to Kirsty and Phil!”

How would a new artist go about protecting their music?

“As a publisher and record label we see it as our job at Audio Network to protect the tracks we represent on behalf of our composers. If you’re unsigned it can be harder work, but in reality not much music gets ‘ripped off’ and you don’t really need to worry about posting CDs to yourself in a sealed envelope. It’s easy to demonstrate when you uploaded a file to iTunes/Soundcloud etc. if you really need to prove you got there first. Don’t sign any of your rights away before you talk to someone who knows their music onions. And then get a second opinion.”

What is the difference between copyright and a trademark?

“I’m not a lawyer, but my understanding is that a trademark is a visual symbol that represents your brand, band name or product and can be registered and protected as long as it’s unique, can’t be confused with anything similar, and continues to be used. A copyright is the legal protection that applies to an intellectual property creation, which can be a song, a recording of a song, a TV show, a book, a computer game etc. A copyright automatically vests with the creator once the creation is ‘fixed’ by recording or transcribing (i.e. it’s not protected when it’s just in your head!), whereas a trademark must be applied for and granted (and can be refused).”

If you had 3 pieces of advice for new artists who don’t know much about the law/business aspect of the music industry?

– “Thankfully there’s a wealth of information out there if you are keen to learn. Some great web sites like http://copyrightuser.org/ and https://www.musictank.co.uk/ as well as industry bodies for performers http://thefac.org/, composers http://basca.org.uk/ and publishers http://www.mpaonline.org.uk/ all have great info on their sites, and more if you become a member.

– “The best book by a mile that I read whilst studying for my LLM is Ann Harrison’s Music: The Business. Clearly written, no jargon, up-to-date and digestible.”

– “There’s also a great series of short courses which is jointly run by the Music Publishers Association and Music Managers Forum http://themmf.net/education/training/ monthly on Monday evenings in London.”

*Bonus advice from Simon* – “Network – talk to people. Share questions, information and ideas. Lobby. The industry is always evolving so there is always new stuff to learn. That also creates opportunities for people to get involved and shape the change.”

A massive thank you to Simon Anderson for participating!

If you have any questions please feel free to comment on this article and I will do my best to answer you.

 

 

Written by: Cherry Johnson

Disclaimer: I am not giving formal legal advice, only the information I gain from research and interviews. If you are unsure of a legal problem you are having please seek advice from a qualified lawyer.

The Basics

… know your terminology and basic contract information.

 

What is a contract?

In the simplest of terms, a contract is a written or spoken agreement between two of more parties that is intended to be enforced by the law of the land.

What are the key elements of a contract?

For a contract to be enforceable legally, it must consist of the following three elements:

  • There must be an offer
  • Acceptance
  • Consideration

What is an offer?

An offer is a manifestation or expression by one party (known as the offeror) to the other party (known as the offeree)

What is the acceptance?

This literally means the ‘acceptance of an offer’. An offer can be accepted by some action or deed by signing a contract to make it official and legal.

What is an agreement?

An agreement requires a meeting of the minds and is usually, but not always, the result of an identifiable offer and acceptance of that offer.

The agreement itself can be expressed in words (written or oral) or implied (from words, conduct, or surrounding circumstances) so be careful what you say or what you sign.

Value of consideration

Consideration passing one way does not have to be equal in value to the consideration passing the other way.

Example: Publishing deals are often done in situations were your catalogue is exchanged in ownership one way and a lot of the time the value is incredibly small, for example £1. The reason for this is that £1 is just a consideration, not the contract. Money HAS to exchange hands for it to be a valid exchange.

The importance of ‘Equal Obligations’

Law originates from ‘welfarism’, which is the public policy promise. Most music industry contracts consist of rights and obligations, they both have rights to something therefore they both have obligations to each other too. There must be a balance of obligations for the contract to be fair for both parties. The obligation is the work, not the money. It is not the number of obligations on each side that matters (quantity). It is the nature of the obligations that must be considered (quality).

Equal bargaining power

An agreement must be negotiated with every attempt being made to ensure each party has the same power to make it fair.

Equal bargaining in dispute

The courts should decide the outcome of a case after giving the same level of benefit to each side’s argument.

 

 

 

 

Disclaimer: I am not giving formal legal advice, only the information I gain from research and interviews. If you are unsure of a legal problem you are having please seek advice from a qualified lawyer.

 

 

Here to help.

Hello and welcome to Always Read The Small Print!

This new blog is all about the world of music law. The goal of this blog is to give advice to start up bands and new artists to help them protect their music and gain basic business and legal knowledge. If you want to know what this blog is going to consist of, please go to the ‘About’ tab to find out a little about the author and more on the blog itself.

The first post will be up soon, thanks for visiting!

Music law logo

 

Written by: Cherry Johnson